NFL Panic Meter: Are Eagles, Steelers and other losing teams from wild-card weekend heading in right direction?
The fallout from NFL wild-card weekend has left several contenders at a crossroads, with the Philadelphia Eagles and Pittsburgh Steelers facing particularly pivotal offseasons.
Philadelphia Eagles: From Potential Dynasty to Offseason Enigma
Last season’s Super Bowl champions entered 2025 with “potential dynasty” buzz but exited with a disappointing loss to San Francisco, sparking questions about their true ceiling. The offense underperformed despite elite talent, and drama around star receiver A.J. Brown has fueled trade speculation. Key veterans like Lane Johnson (36), Dallas Goedert (31), and Saquon Barkley (29) are at ages where decline becomes a real concern. While a full teardown is unlikely given the roster’s talent, significant changes—particularly at offensive coordinator—are inevitable. The Eagles remain one of the offseason’s most fascinating teams, capable of bouncing back as a Super Bowl favorite or continuing a frustrating slide.
Panic Meter: Moderate. Changes are needed, but the foundation for contention remains.
Pittsburgh Steelers: An Era Ends, Uncertainty Begins
Mike Tomlin’s resignation after 19 seasons marks the start of a rare organizational reset. The Steelers, blown out 30-6 by Houston, haven’t been true title contenders in years and now face questions at quarterback (with Aaron Rodgers unlikely to return) and across an aging defense. A roster overhaul appears likely regardless of the new head coach. This offseason represents the franchise’s most critical transition in decades, with short-term pain probable as they seek a new identity.
Panic Meter: High. A rebuild seems inevitable, and stability is no longer guaranteed.
Carolina Panthers: Moral Victories Foster Hope
Despite an 8-10 record, the Panthers showed tangible progress, pushing the Rams to the brink in the wild-card round. Young receivers Tetairoa McMillan and Jalen Coker offer promise, and stability under head coach Dave Canales provides rare continuity. The key remains quarterback Bryce Young’s development into a more prolific passer. For a franchise mired in dysfunction, this season offered a genuine foundation for optimism.
Panic Meter: Low. There’s finally a constructive direction and young talent to build around.
Green Bay Packers: Sky Isn’t Falling After Collapse
A five-game losing streak—including a playoff meltdown against Chicago—casts a dark shadow, but the Packers’ core remains strong. Key injuries (Micah Parsons, Tucker Kraft) devastated the defense, and a young roster should continue to mature. Matt LaFleur returns under pressure, but Green Bay is well-positioned to rebound.
Panic Meter: Low. This is a setback, not a collapse, for a talented young team.
Jacksonville Jaguars: Sustaining Success the Next Challenge
A stunning 13-4 season under first-year coach Liam Coen ended abruptly, but the Jaguars’ rise was no fluke (ranked sixth in DVOA). The challenge now is avoiding the regression that often follows a breakout year. With a solid foundation and coaching, Jacksonville should remain in the playoff mix.
Panic Meter: Low. Expectation management is key, but the trajectory remains positive.
Los Angeles Chargers: Playoff Curse Overshadows Contender Status
For the second straight year, the Chargers were the postseason’s most disappointing team, failing to score a touchdown against New England. Jim Harbaugh’s leadership keeps them in perennial contention, but retaining defensive coordinator Jesse Minter (a head-coaching candidate) is critical. Health along the offensive line (Rashawn Slater, Joe Alt) will also dictate their ceiling. The pieces are there—if they can solve their playoff woes.
Panic Meter: Moderate. The playoff failures are concerning, but the roster and coaching inspire confidence.
.jpg)
.jpg)
