‘The inconsistency is f***ing crazy.’ Refs behind sudden scoring decline?
A dramatic and sudden decline in free throws has triggered a league-wide scoring slump in January, igniting frustration among players and coaches, upending sportsbooks, and reviving questions about officiating consistency.
Player and Coach Outcry Reaches Boiling Point
The issue came to a head when Boston Celtics star Jaylen Brown, after attempting 23 drives without a single free throw in a January 10 loss, launched a fiery critique of officiating, stating, "The inconsistency is f***ing crazy." He was fined $35,000, joining a growing list of penalized players and coaches, including Dillon Brooks, Marcus Smart, and three head coaches fined in quick succession. Celtics coach Joe Mazzulla recently mocked officials over a missed illegal screen call, highlighting the simmering tensions.
Scoring Collapse Sends Sportsbooks Scrambling
The on-court shift has had a direct financial impact. Free-throw attempts per 100 possessions have plummeted nearly 20% from October to January, wiping roughly eight points per game off the board. This has caused a historic run for "under" bets on point totals. In January, unders have cashed at a staggering 64.7% rate, compared to a typical 50% split, forcing sportsbooks to repeatedly lower over/under lines in a futile attempt to catch up. One professional bettor described the situation as "printing money."
A Familiar Pattern Raises Questions of Stealth Adjustment
The trend mirrors a similar midseason scoring drop in early 2024, which the NBA initially denied but later acknowledged was an intentional "adjustment" to rebalance offense and defense. While the league has not issued any memo to teams this time, internal analytics groups have flagged the new trends to front offices. The data points to specific changes: the rate of fouls called on 3-point attempts has fallen 26% since October, virtually eliminating a major source of easy points for prolific shooters like Jalen Brunson and Donovan Mitchell. Fouls on 2-point attempts have also slightly declined.
The Search for Consistency and Normalcy
Despite the drop in shooting fouls, the foul rate on drives has remained steady, adding to perceptions of inconsistency. The league faces mounting pressure from all sides—teams seeking predictable officiating, sportsbooks needing accurate data, and fans watching a transformed product. Whether January's tighter whistle represents a permanent correction or another temporary adjustment remains the critical, unanswered question at the heart of the NBA's latest officiating storm.
.webp)
