Nolan Arenado trade is win for Diamondbacks amid limited options for Cardinals
The St. Louis Cardinals have completed their long-anticipated separation from star third baseman Nolan Arenado, trading the future Hall of Fame candidate to the Arizona Diamondbacks for minor league pitcher Jack Martinez, an eighth-round 2025 draft pick who has yet to throw a professional inning.
The move, while stark in its imbalance, is the culmination of a mutual desire for a fresh start. The Cardinals sought to unload the remaining $42 million on Arenado’s contract as they pivot toward a rebuild, while the 34-year-old veteran, wielding a full no-trade clause, prioritized joining a contender. St. Louis will cover $31 million of Arenado’s salary over the next two seasons, leaving Arizona responsible for just $11 million.
Arenado’s decline in recent seasons heavily influenced the minimal return. After a stellar 2022 campaign (third in NL MVP voting) and an All-Star first half in 2023, his production has sharply fallen. Over the past two seasons, his 95 wRC+ ranks 107th among 120 qualified hitters, and his once-elite defense has regressed to merely above average.
For the Diamondbacks, the acquisition addresses a perceived need at third base after trade rumors involving Ketel Marte and interest in free agent Alex Bregman (who signed with the Cubs) failed to materialize. The move signals a preference for veteran certainty over entrusting the position to top prospect Jordan Lawlar, who has struggled to stay healthy and establish himself in the majors.
Arenado brings a decorated résumé—10 Gold Gloves, 8 All-Star selections—but notably lacks postseason success, having never advanced beyond the Division Series in four career playoff appearances. Joining a young, competitive Arizona roster offers him a final opportunity to chase October glory at a bargain price for the Diamondbacks.
The trade underscores the harsh reality of aging stars with burdensome contracts: even future Hall of Famers can become financial liabilities, with their trade value dictated more by salary relief and fit than by past accolades.
